French cosmetics firm L’Oreal (OREP.PA) is buying 8 percent of its shares from Swiss food group Nestle (NESN.VX) for 6.5 billion euros ($9 billion), loosening their 40-year partnership and allowing both firms to boost earnings per share.
However, Nestle said on Tuesday the deal was not the start of a full exit from L’Oreal, leaving some uncertainty over the future of its remaining 23 percent stake in the maker of Garnier shampoo and Lancome creams.
“This transaction is a bit of a letdown,” Liberum Capital analysts said in a note, referring to media reports that L’Oreal might buy a larger proportion or even all of Nestle’s stake.
“We assume speculation may continue regarding Nestle’s future plans. Sell to a third party? Sell more in the future to L’Oreal?”
At 0940 GMT L’Oreal shares, which had leapt on Monday on speculation of a larger stake purchase, were down 2 percent at 126.4 euros. Shares in Nestle, home to Gerber baby food and Kit Kat chocolate bars, were down 1 percent at 66.9 Swiss francs.
“I do not see this as a first step of leaving L’Oréal … not at all,” Nestle Chairman Peter Brabeck told reporters, describing the Swiss group’s stake in L’Oreal as “strategic”.
“We are in here for the long haul,” he added.
Nestle became a L’Oreal shareholder in 1974 to protect the group from being nationalized if the Socialists took power.
Under their pact, Nestle and L’Oreal heiress, Liliane Bettencourt, the world’s richest woman, promised not to sell their stakes without first offering them to the other until April 29, 2014 – 40 years after the initial deal was signed.
L’Oreal, which on Monday posted forecast-beating quarterly sales, will cancel all the shares it buys from Nestle, boosting its earnings per share by more than 5 percent.
However, it will have to wait to buy more shares – if it is offered the opportunity – as French rules put limits on how regularly companies can cancel shares.
The deal will cut Nestle’s stake in L’Oreal to 23.29 percent from 29.4 percent while the Bettencourt Meyers family’s stake in L’Oréal will increase from 30.6 percent to 33.31 percent.
L’Oreal Chief Executive Jean-Paul Agon explained how the two European consumer goods groups agreed on the 8 percent figure:
“Nestle’s stake reduction had to allow it to remain a strategic shareholder … while making sure that the Bettencourt family stayed below the 33.33 percent level.” Beyond that level, the family would have to make an offer for the rest of L’Oreal’s share capital.
The deal will be funded by 3.4 billion euros in cash and the sale by L’Oreal to Nestle of its 50 percent stake in their Galderma dermatology joint venture for 3.1 billion euros including debt, paid by Nestlé in L’Oréal shares
Nestle said it would use the cash proceeds to launch a share buyback, without disclosing details.
“In reality, I think it is as close to maintaining the status quo as politically possible given L’Oreal’s desire to take some of the stake back and the fact Nestlé didn’t need to sell,” Jon Cox, analyst at Kepler Cheuvreux said.
The Swiss group, which has been developing its health and wellness operations in recent years, is trying to maximize its use of capital and dispose of non-core assets.
The price per L’Oreal share used for the transaction is 124.48 euros, corresponding to its average closing price between November 11, 2013 and February 10, 2014.
L’Oreal said the deal would not involve selling its 9 percent stake in drugmaker Sanofi (SASY.PA), worth $12 billion. Sanofi shares fell 1.4 percent. Analysts believe Sanofi could have boosted earnings by buying back L’Oreal’s stake.
In order to reflect the change of Nestle’s stake in L’Oreal’s governance, the number of Nestle representatives on L’Oreal’s board of directors will be cut from three to two.